By: Jesse Striewski

I was really hoping for yet another diamond in the rough horror film in the same vain of this year’s Black Phone 2. Unfortunately with this latest update to 1984’s Silent Night, Deadly Night, there’s more “rough” than anything else here.

First the pros; the visuals and atmosphere are fairly spot on, and even some of the eerie music from the original film (see, “Santa’s Watching”) is used, which brings a nice touch to the proceedings. And Rohan Campbell is actually pretty convincing as the disturbed drifter Billy, as is Ruby Modine as his love interest, Pam (for the most part, anyway).

Now the cons; it’s an-over-the top gorefest where any chance at actual art is pushed aside to make way for another stab at shock value. We’re expected to accept an unrealistic and exaggerated reality where anyone religious/bearing a cross is seemingly inherently evil in a fairly insulting manner. Even the gimmick of Billy hearing and responding to an inner voice named Charlie (voiced by Mark Acheson) quickly becomes fairly tiresome here.

Sure, the original film was far from perfect (I won’t even get into the various levels of its sequels right now, either) and you won’t ever hear me claim otherwise. But where part of Billy’s traumas were the result from the abuse he encountered from the head nun at the orphanage he was raised in, there was also the contrast from the younger, decent nun who wanted to actually help Billy and see him thrive in life. Here there’s nothing like that, just another dumbed-down excuse for excess violence.

What starts with a decent concept, quickly gets muddled by excess violence and a predictable ending. The potential was there, but the execution is simply not as clever as the filmmakers had hoped it would be here.

Rating: 2/5 Stars