
By: Jesse Striewski
I’m really not sure why I even continue trying to convince myself that each new Walking Dead spinoff or as with this case, sequel series, will somehow improve, when each time it’s more of the same tired formula; good guys find a new home that gives them a temporary false sense of security, then bad guys (often someone from within their group these days) threaten that safety.
Dead City is really just more of the same; it starts out promising enough, but just ends up more of the same as previously mentioned. This time our hero leftovers from the original show Maggie (Lauren Cohan) and Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) team up to reinforce a New York hospital with brother and sister duo Luis (Raul Castillo) and Reneta (Aimee Garcia), a doctor and “community leader,” respectively, at the helm.
There’s even an interesting, eccentric new character in the form of Dillard (Jimmi Simpson) who’s spent his time in the apocalypse in a lonesome bar with a couple of walkers, that befriends Negan. But where there’s potential, there’s more of the same, predictable developmental let down as usual.
Perhaps the only real standout of the season is the “what if,” zombie-less episode that has Maggie and Negan meeting in the pre-apocalypse real world that also features a guest spot from Maggie’s long-since deceased sister, Beth (Emily Kinney). The only downfall with this is the weak portrayal of Negan, who instead of being seen as some tough-as-nails, outlaw biker type that we all grew to hate when initially introduced, is reduced to a sensitive teacher type in order to make him more like-able to audiences prior to his going bad. (A huge misstep in my opinion.)
I’ve actually been re-watching a lot of the older Walking Dead seasons (the pre-Negan days, a.k.a. the show’s prime), and the difference is night and day, with the writing, acting, and overall quality declining more and more with each new passing season and iteration. If these characters must continue on (as I’m sure they will), perhaps the writers of these episodes could go back and take some lessons on how things were done when it was actually in good hands what now feels like a lifetime ago.
Rating: 2/5 Stars




